Solve : Using different brands of RAM in a dual-channel configuration?

1.	Solve : Using different brands of RAM in a dual-channel configuration?
Answer» Hi all. I have a Gateway E4100 desktop running Windows XP. This is a single-core computer with four RAM slots on the motherboard to provide dual-channel memory. You're supposed to have identical paired DIMMs on both channels to let you run in dual-channel mode. I'm planning to use a pair of unbuffered sticks of 512 MB Crucial brand DDR in one channel and a pair of 512 MB DDR Corsair brand in the other channel, ALSO unbuffered. Does anyone know if performance would be enhanced by using the same brand in all four slots? Or decreased by using different brands? I thought since the pair in channel A would be identical and likewise the pair in channel B it should work fine, but I'd LIKE a second opinion. Thanks in advance.Quote from: comporanger on July 25, 2011, 04:15:50 PM ...You're supposed to have identical paired DIMMs on both channels to let you run in dual-channel mode.... No, the 2 pairs need not be identical. Therefore, both pairs need not be the same. I have a computer with a pair of 1GB & a pair of 256MB. BTW, there is no setup or configuration for dual channel. It either works or doesn't, but you'll probably not notice the difference, either way.Quote from: Computer_Commando on July 25, 2011, 04:34:31 PM No, the 2 pairs need not be identical. Therefore, both pairs need not be the same. I have a computer with a pair of 1GB & a pair of 256MB. BTW, there is no setup or configuration for dual channel. It either works or doesn't, but you'll probably not notice the difference, either way. Correct. Usually for dual channel to work, however the sticks have to be identical in size, and the sticks have to have a common timing. I have had two different DDR2 800 2GB sticks in dual channel, however they only ran at the common timing of 667 until i swapped for two identcal sticks.Quote from: Kurtiskain on July 25, 2011, 05:09:21 PM ...however the sticks have to be identical in size, and the sticks have to have a common timing... Not all 4 sticks, only the individual pairs need be matched.Quote from: Computer_Commando on July 25, 2011, 05:31:24 PM Not all 4 sticks, only the individual pairs need be matched. True. I was describing a 2 slot only situation You are correct; the slots are colour coded, and the sticks should be matched to the colours. Purple with purple, orange with orange ect...Performance increase is MARGINAL at best: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual-channel_architecture

Answer»

Hi all. I have a Gateway E4100 desktop running Windows XP. This is a single-core computer with four RAM slots on the motherboard to provide dual-channel memory. You're supposed to have identical paired DIMMs on both channels to let you run in dual-channel mode. I'm planning to use a pair of unbuffered sticks of 512 MB Crucial brand DDR in one channel and a pair of 512 MB DDR Corsair brand in the other channel, ALSO unbuffered. Does anyone know if performance would be enhanced by using the same brand in all four slots? Or decreased by using different brands? I thought since the pair in channel A would be identical and likewise the pair in channel B it should work fine, but I'd LIKE a second opinion. Thanks in advance.Quote from: comporanger on July 25, 2011, 04:15:50 PM

...You're supposed to have identical paired DIMMs on both channels to let you run in dual-channel mode....

No, the 2 pairs need not be identical. Therefore, both pairs need not be the same.
I have a computer with a pair of 1GB & a pair of 256MB. BTW, there is no setup or configuration for dual channel. It either works or doesn't, but you'll probably not notice the difference, either way.Quote from: Computer_Commando on July 25, 2011, 04:34:31 PM

No, the 2 pairs need not be identical. Therefore, both pairs need not be the same.
I have a computer with a pair of 1GB & a pair of 256MB. BTW, there is no setup or configuration for dual channel. It either works or doesn't, but you'll probably not notice the difference, either way.

Correct. Usually for dual channel to work, however the sticks have to be identical in size, and the sticks have to have a common timing. I have had two different DDR2 800 2GB sticks in dual channel, however they only ran at the common timing of 667 until i swapped for two identcal sticks.Quote from: Kurtiskain on July 25, 2011, 05:09:21 PM

...however the sticks have to be identical in size, and the sticks have to have a common timing...

Not all 4 sticks, only the individual pairs need be matched.Quote from: Computer_Commando on July 25, 2011, 05:31:24 PM

Not all 4 sticks, only the individual pairs need be matched.

True. I was describing a 2 slot only situation You are correct; the slots are colour coded, and the sticks should be matched to the colours. Purple with purple, orange with orange ect...Performance increase is MARGINAL at best: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual-channel_architecture

Solve : Using different brands of RAM in a dual-channel configuration?

Discussion

No Comment Found

Related InterviewSolutions

Reply to Comment