InterviewSolution
| 1. |
Solve : Why use for twisted-pair instead of coaxial cable?? |
|
Answer» My best guess is that it's more economical. But it may be that it's easier to install. Or perhaps there is an advantage to better bandwidth, but I'm not too sure about that. For strictly TV viewing needs, the RG6 cable is esential for your HDTV. While the Cat6 can be useful, it is only required for the secondary data uses of the HDTV.No proof given. I am hoping to find a real Electronic Engineer who is not a typical tech writer. for me, the answer lies in the availability of those 10base2 cards - in other words, where are they all? Quote from: Mark. on August 13, 2018, 05:50:26 AM for me, the answer lies in the availability of those 10base2 cards - in other words, where are they all?There are some still out there. Somewhere. Maybe. To be useful, two are needed. Here is yet another nice explanation of coax, but it does not say why everybody went to UTP. (Un-shielded Twisted Pair.) http://www.informit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=683070&seqNum=2 The author has credentials. In fact, she says: Quote coax provides from 370 to 1,000 times more capacity than single twisted-pair.Do the math, anybody? EDIT:This link only claims UTP is more easy to install. https://www.wireandcabletips.com/when-should-i-use-twisted-pair-versus-coaxial-cables/ Quote ... The biggest advantage to twisted pair cabling is in installation, as it is often thinner than coax.I don't thin k so. Of course the 10base2 cards created before could still be around. I think Mark is pointing out that you can't go to the shop and buy a 10base2 PCI-E Card, and 10base2 isn't built into motherboards. Quote from: Geek-9pm on August 12, 2018, 11:24:14 PM If RG6 coax is so much better, Why use CAT6 cable? Isn't that leading your google search with an assumption, though? Because the entire reason for your query is to determine what makes UTP or STP cable better for modern networks, so you can't just start out with the assertion that RG6 Coaxial cable is "so much better"- that's going to lead your results. Coaxial cable is more prone to crosstalk, interference, and induction, and it is also more expensive. UTP is much cheaper and is less susceptible to those electromagnetic issues than EVEN shielded coaxial cable. This was found relatively early on- 802.3e has the first UTP standards. It was more standardized to standard ethernet protocols in 802.3i. Twisted-pair is also necessary for high-speed ethernet. But hold a second, you might think- "But Internet is coming in over a coax via Cable internet!" Which is correct. But that information is Analog information, which is why you need a modem. Ethernet is a digital protocol which means it would be far more sensitive to the electronic weaknesses of coaxial cable, which was actually the case in practice. 802.3u dropped Coax as a standard connection type with 100mbps Ethernet, which in the standards is only done with Twisted Pair cables or Fiber optic cables. That is why 10/100 cards sometimes have BNC or a connection for an ATTACHMENT Unit Interface (That 15 pin thing), which were standards for 10Mbit Ethernet, but Ethernet cards that don't support 10mbps Ethernet standards at all don't have those connections, since 100 mbps Ethernet cannot use those connectors or their cables as part of the standards.Thank yu for your reply,BC. How can I use Google for an answer that is very clear and explains things clearly? Grated, there is a lot of coax already in use by the TV cable companies. Is it any factor the resewn they stick with coax? Also, is not Digital better than Analog? And is it not true that the USA has moved from Analog to Digital TV? So then, why not just use CAT5 to drop all services to a new house? Could you not have telephone, Internet and 100 channels of digital TV on one CAT5 cable? When I was a youngster I was deep into the math stuff and could CALCULATE some of the things in theoretical communications media. .But the technology moves so fast that I am left behind. Many of the tech writers seem to water stuff down so much that you can not tell what is verifiable and what is not. Do you have some links that show CAT6 is better than coax for short haul data? (Of course for long distance and high speed your either go microwave or fiber optic. That has been true for some time, with fiber overtaking microwave is many applications. But fiber has a latency issue at the present time.) Quote Grated, there is a lot of coax already in use by the TV cable companies. Is it any factor the resewn they stick with coax? BC explained this above...re-read his Post...I think it is like Betamax versus VHS - didn't matter who came first or which was better - for whatever reason (yeah, I know it was the porn market) the industry went with VHS. same with this coax versus ethernet - coax is dead (for networking), long live ethernet. I think Geek, even if you research the crap out of this, and maybe even came to the conclusion coax is the answer, you just can't buy them any more, no one supports it and none exist out there in the real world now days.Mark, I have done some research and I am not going to buy the equipment. Direct TV does have a kit for people who want to run Ethernet over the coax that runs around the house. It is some on Amazon. It is for people who hate CAT6 and want to use the coax they have. Much too expensive for me. Got to Amazon and search for Ethernet over Coax and find a kit from Direct TV. |
|